BARR Advisory vs Schellman: SOC 2 Auditor Comparison
Compare BARR Advisory and Schellman using proposals for the same system, report type, criteria, and period. Evaluate the assigned personnel, independence, evidence process, qualifications, and commercial terms. This guide provides a decision framework rather than an unsupported ranking of fees, firm size, customer satisfaction, or delivery speed.
Key Takeaways
- •Compare the named engagement team and scope, not unsupported firm-wide rankings.
- •Verify current qualifications with the relevant program or professional registry.
- •Obtain comparable proposals before drawing conclusions about cost or delivery.
What should a BARR Advisory versus Schellman comparison establish?
Start with the assurance your customer needs. AICPA & CIMA describes SOC as CPA assurance services; a particular engagement still needs an agreed system boundary, criteria, report type, and period. Give both firms the same requirements so differences in proposals are visible.
Ask each firm to identify the legal entity providing the service and the people responsible for the engagement. Verify applicable professional standing, relevant experience, independence, and any program-specific qualifications. A broad brand description does not establish who will perform the work.
This comparison does not use founding dates, employee-count estimates, or assumed market positioning to predict audit quality. It also does not establish that either firm is universally cheaper, more responsive, or better suited to every startup.
How do the proposals compare directly?
Use the same evaluation questions for both firms and retain their written answers. Distinguish a confirmed commitment from an assumption in a sales discussion.
| Decision | Ask BARR Advisory | Ask Schellman |
|---|---|---|
| Engagement scope | Which system, criteria, period, and deliverables are included? | Which system, criteria, period, and deliverables are included? |
| Personnel | Who leads the engagement and performs the testing? | Who leads the engagement and performs the testing? |
| Evidence workflow | Which exports, records, interviews, and review steps are expected? | Which exports, records, interviews, and review steps are expected? |
| Independence | How are potential conflicts and readiness work handled? | How are potential conflicts and readiness work handled? |
| Commercial terms | Which exclusions and additional-work charges apply? | Which exclusions and additional-work charges apply? |
| Scheduling | Which milestones depend on our readiness or third parties? | Which milestones depend on our readiness or third parties? |
Request clarification where one proposal includes services that the other excludes. Separate software subscriptions, implementation work, and independent assessment fees. Renewal terms and scope changes can matter as much as the initial quote.
How should framework coverage be verified?
Ask each firm to confirm the specific services it can provide and the legal entity holding any required qualification. SOC, ISO certification, PCI DSS validation, and federal assessment work should not be treated as interchangeable credentials.
For PCI DSS, consult the PCI Security Standards Council’s QSA directory. The Council advises checking current standing when engaging an assessor. Do not infer that BARR lacks PCI capability or that Schellman’s name alone establishes the qualification for the proposed work.
For other programs, use the relevant current registry and request evidence from the provider. Keep a dated record of the verification and the exact service covered. If subcontractors are involved, establish who is accountable for delivery.
When should you engage a readiness partner?
An auditor evaluates the agreed subject matter; your organization remains responsible for operating its controls and preparing accurate records. If ownership, remediation, or evidence collection is incomplete, address those gaps before treating an audit booking as a readiness plan.
Review Agency’s audit partners, prepare the auditor PBC list, and clarify what evidence auditors ask for. Keep implementation support and independent assessment responsibilities explicit.
If you add another candidate, such as Auditsuisse Assurance, apply the same diligence questions. Inclusion here is not evidence of comparative pricing, geographic acceptance, or audit outcomes.
How should you choose an auditor or plan a switch?
Choose using documented requirements and the specific engagement offered. Ask intended report users about their acceptance requirements, resolve material exclusions, and confirm the people and milestones in the statement of work.
When considering a switch, discuss the existing reporting period, outstanding work, evidence availability, and customer commitments with the relevant firms. Obtain a transition plan before terminating an engagement. Neither a new firm nor a reused software platform removes the need to demonstrate that controls operated as represented.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is BARR Advisory or Schellman better for a startup?
Which firm costs less?
How should PCI DSS qualifications be checked?
Can a company change SOC 2 audit firms?

Tyler Carbone
Managing Director and Cofounder
Tyler Carbone is a Managing Director and Cofounder of Agency and one of the industry's leading voices on governance, risk, and compliance. He holds degrees from Harvard and a JD/MBA from the University of Virginia, and previously worked in cybersecurity at Deloitte. Tyler has helped hundreds of companies operate SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, and GDPR programs.
LinkedIn